Welcome to Tavern On The Mall
Nestled in the heart of Forestville, NY, Tavern On The Mall is a charming eatery that blends rustic charm with a welcoming atmosphere. This unassuming tavern has garnered rave reviews for its inviting service and hearty portions, making it a local favorite. Patrons delight in the perfectly fried fish, including haddock and perch, as well as their acclaimed wings—crispy, tender, and bursting with flavor. The bar offers an array of cold beers, conducive to lively conversations among patrons, fostering a sense of community. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Tavern On The Mall promises a memorable dining experience filled with warmth and authenticity.
Tavern On The Mall: Reviews & Ratings
The service was great and the food was filling it was cleanandwell set-up. The portions were good size and the price wasn't bad.
We are new to the area and wanted to explore. Who knew there would be a top notch tavern in this beautiful, rural town? Our beers were cold, cold (on an usually warm autumn day) and poured by the friendliest bar tenders. We may have been the only people in there who didn't farm, but we were accepted as part of the crew. It's the kind of place where everyone talks to each other. Politics never came up (whew). We felt very comfortable as a queer couple and so enjoyed the evening. We want to go back and try everything on the food menu, but we started with fish. I got the haddock. My spouse got the perch. Both beer battered. We decided mine was slightly better but wow, both were delicious and fried to perfection. Not greasy at all. Fresh fish. Crunchy goodness.
As a 60 year old native western New Yorker whose been chowing down on wings for the past 50+ years at every opportunity, I will say that the wings we ate here at Tavern On The Mall were absolutely perfect. Finally, a place worthy of a long drive in the country just for the wings. From that first very crispy bite I was enamored with these wings because they were cooked to perfection with a beautifully crisp skin that was holding in the moist & tender flesh of these wings. Also worthy of the drive was the friendly customer service extended to us by the young man who was working by himself behind the bar and in the kitchen. We were very happy to have arrived at a time when there were only 3 groups of people in the bar and the young man was not over whelmed with demanding customers. He & I were able to have a very pleasant discussion about the local area and how I remember this establishment doing business under the name of the Wilcox Hotel back in the 1970's. Us old folks like to reminisce because we've already made a lifetime's worth of memories, and this young man was courteous enough to listen to my ramblings. Thank you Tavern On The Mall for creating another pleasant memory for a seasoned citizen.
Menu is improving! Social media post keep us updated with specials and events. Staff and food is great.
Stopped in for fish on a Friday. Great choice. It's a no frills bar/ restaurant in the center of a small town, but the food did not disappoint. Serval varieties of fish. My sister got the country fried on a recommendation and it didn't disappoint. Think county fried steak batter on haddock fish. Yum. They had serval different, original wing flavors as well. Nice and crispy. They offer 3, 50 cent wing nights a week. I know Sunday was one, can't remember the other 2. Stop in if you're passing through.
Location
-
14 Main St Forestville, NY 14062 Hotline: (716) 965-9783
Welcome to Tavern On The Mall, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Forestville, NY, at 14 Main St. This rustic tavern embodies the charm of small-town dining while offering a delightful twist on classic flavors and hearty fare. With its inviting ambiance, friendly staff, and a menu that caters to both locals and visitors alike, Tavern On The Mall has quickly become a beloved stop for anyone looking to enjoy a meal worth savoring.
Why does this tavern stand out? Here are just a few highlights:
- Community Atmosphere: Step inside and you'll immediately feel at home. The tavern fosters a sense of camaraderie among its patrons, as you’ll find neighbors chatting away with one another. You might even find yourself sharing a table with locals, discussing everything from farming to life in the area—minus the politics!
- Exquisite Fish Dishes: The menu boasts standout seafood options, with fried fish like haddock and perch prepared to absolute perfection. Customers rave about the light, crispy batter, which enhances the fresh fish without overwhelming it, making it a must-try for seafood lovers.
- A Wings Experience Like No Other: If you consider yourself a wing aficionado, then Tavern On The Mall is your destination. The wings here are crispy and tender, expertly cooked to achieve a perfect balance of flavor and texture. Guests have referred to them as “absolutely perfect,” a testament to the kitchen’s skill.
- Helpful Staff: The service at Tavern On The Mall receives frequent praise, with patrons describing the staff as friendly and accommodating. Whether you're coming in for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, you'll find a warm welcome and attentive service.
- Specials and Events: The tavern keeps things fresh with regular specials and events, shared on their social media to keep you updated. This means there's always something new to try, so you’ll never run out of reasons to return!
No visit to Tavern On The Mall would be complete without indulging in their signature dishes. On Fridays, the fish fry is a highlight, while wings fly off the menu on several evenings throughout the week for just 50 cents each. It’s an inviting spot that even encourages newcomers—one couple noted how welcomed they felt, enjoying their time as if they were part of the family.
In a town where good food meets good company, Tavern On The Mall delivers delightful dining experiences that resonate with hearts and palates alike. So, whether you're passing through or looking for a cozy dinner out, make sure to stop by and discover what this charming tavern has to offer. Remember, the dining experience here is not just about the meals; it's about the memories you'll create along the way.
